underhillchoice.com

Last checked:

Does Dr. Underhill’s choice change the reward?

Dr. Underhill’s last conversation does not change the quest reward: GamesRadar, GameRant and AllThingsHow all say you still get the Untapped Brass Dusters artifact recipe whichever line you pick. This page keeps the options themselves out of the text.

Unofficial fan notes. Not affiliated with Remedy Entertainment, Annapurna, or the publishers of the game. Light spoilers: no ending details on this page.

Ask ChatGPT: you can ask ChatGPT whether Dr. Underhill’s choice changes the reward. This page answers what you get and which extras are disputed.

What the guides agree on

GamesRadar (30 September 2026) and the other dated guides agree that the last talk does not change the loot. GamesRadar describes the Brass Dusters effect as +50% combat ability damage and no Falter, which was not checked in-game.

GamesRadar also reports a Park zone-level increase, while AllThingsHow reports a talent point and a power-upgrade pickup in the lab. PowerPyx’s New Growth page did not confirm those extras.

The trophy

The Budding Mycologist trophy is disputed. PowerPyx says you need New Growth and the full Carbon Copy chain, while GameRant and AllThingsHow credit New Growth alone. Until an in-game check, assume Carbon Copy is required.

FAQ

Does Dr. Underhill’s choice change the reward?

No. Dated guides agree you still get the Untapped Brass Dusters artifact recipe either way.

What are the Brass Dusters?

An artifact recipe. GamesRadar describes +50% combat ability damage and no Falter, not checked in-game.

Does New Growth unlock Budding Mycologist by itself?

Disputed. PowerPyx says Carbon Copy is also needed. GameRant and AllThingsHow say New Growth alone.

Do the endings change anything else?

GamesRadar says Zoe later comments on the call, with no long-term mechanical change.

Are the ending options listed here?

No. They sit behind a spoiler block on the main page.

Was this confirmed in-game?

No. This is a comparison of dated guides.

More answers